The Babington Arms in Derby closed last week as a JD Wetherspoon venue and has reopened nearly immediately under the same name but operated by a private company. So, rather belatedly, I thought I’d better note my experiences of visiting this pub in the past and how it was really rather one of my favourites.
The chain explained why they had given the pub the name that they did in 1997:
“This pub’s site was once part of the gardens immediately behind the long-demolished Babington House. This 17th-century mansion was the home of the Babington family, whose coat of arms depicted two baboons on a large beer or wine cask.”
I’ve been here a few times over the last couple of years and it’s a comfortable pub, but it did feel in need of a renovation. The price point was the lowest in the chain, despite them having another pub around a ten minute walk away which has higher prices.
This does feel like those JD Wetherspoon pubs that opened in the 1990s, lots of wood and a traditional feel. This venue felt more like a pub than some of their other locations, it evidently had a community and loyal set of locals. It was also quite a small pub for the chain, which is perhaps the reason that they no longer wanted it.
The real ale selection in June 2025, which was all keenly priced and a perfectly decent selection.
And a small breakfast which I recall was entirely as I would want it to be
I mentioned the refurbishment that was needed earlier and this little waterfall arrangement last year was perhaps testament to that.
Having a look at previous reviews, there’s the near obligatory one that someone has gone to a chain that doesn’t allow dogs and is annoyed that their dog isn’t allowed in.
“Cannot go inside or outside with my dog. Obviously they do not want regular customers that are sensible. I feel discriminated against, when I am willing to sit outside with the smokers, in the rain. Most pubs in Derby are pub friendly. DOWN MARKET WETHERSPOON WHAT A LOAD OF CRAP.”
Anyway…
“Only one checkout working all week, large queues on self-service and checkout. Customers moaning about the service. What a way to lose a lot of customers.”
How on earth can someone get a pub confused with a supermarket?
“This place starts selling alcohol at 8am. I don’t drink at that time but often take a morning walk. For years I’ve ordered a pint of soda and lime with just a single measure of lime. Soda water is free so I’ve just paid for the lime, which has recently increased from 20p to 55p. Still I don’t mind this as the company has rent and other costs to cater for.
Last time I was there they said I had to pay for 2 measures of lime because I wanted a pint drink. The manager confirmed to me that I had to pay for something I wasn’t buying!!! This company has two other pubs in Derby who don’t do this. This pub is blatantly biased against none alcoholics.
After contacting their head office, I confirmed that soda water is free. My tip to help change this rip off is to order a small soda and lime and then as many free pints of soda water as you like. More work for the staff, more washing up and a chance of changing policy.”
The last paragraph tells me what I need to know about the customer, but this was back in the day when venues were allowed to reply, and the manager at the time responded with “you are entitled to your opinion” and I like this sort of passive aggressive response.
Anyway, the reviews from the first new days of the new operator aren’t great, but I don’t envy them. Taking over a new pub is hard enough, but it’s especially difficult when you’re following a JD Wetherspoon with its cheap prices, generally efficient service and the wide selection of food and drink. Fair play to anyone for trying though as they’ve at least kept the pub open.